Luckily Qld property prices never reached crazy levels that NSW’s and Victoria’s did – now less room to fall

Michael Janda at ABC News has a good summary of the residential property price data for December quarter published yesterday by the ABS:

Australia’s $133 billion property price slide rapidly becoming the worst in modern history

This correction has been a long time coming. Then RBA Governor Glenn Stevens warned about Sydney’s “crazy” house prices in mid-2015. Incidentally, following the Governor’s comments which were made at an ESA Queensland business lunch,  I set a UQ ECON2040 Macroeconomic Policy assignment on the implications for monetary policy of the housing price bubble. And in early 2017 I posted:

Sydney & Melbourne house prices defy rational explanation

As I’ve noted in a previous post, Howard Marks’s 2018 book Mastering the Market Cycle is recommended reading on economic cycles and the implications for investing, and he is especially lucid on real estate (on p. 169):

Much of investing is subject to gross generalizations and sweeping statements—usually stressing the positives, because of humans’ tendency toward greed and wishful thinking—and for some reason this seems particularly true in real estate. Over the course of my career I’ve heard investment in real estate rationalized by easily digested statements like “they’re not making any more” (in connection with land), “you can always live in it” (in connection with houses), and “it’s a hedge against inflation”…What people eventually learn is that regardless of the merit behind the statements, they won’t protect an investment that was made at too high a price.

A lot of investors in the Sydney and Melbourne markets are learning that now, and we are now seeing an adverse wealth effect drag on consumption spending. Luckily Queensland property prices never reached the crazy levels they did in Sydney and Melbourne and falls in local property prices have been slight so far (see chart below), with the exception of inner-Brisbane city apartments. Partly, that would have been because we have had more mixed economic circumstances than other states in recent years.


As I’ve noted before, I undertake my data analysis and charting using R, the data science programming language, which I can’t recommend highly enough. I’m trying to convert others to using R and am running an upcoming course:

Data science with R: Introduction with a focus on ABS economic data

If you regularly analyse and chart ABS data, I would recommend attending my training day and learning how you can save huge amounts of time in your data analysis and charting. The early bird registration fee expires this Friday.

This entry was posted in Housing, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Luckily Qld property prices never reached crazy levels that NSW’s and Victoria’s did – now less room to fall

  1. Russell Rogers says:

    Gene, a fair overall statement that our prise drop is less because they did not rise as much. But, I will offer a further comment. I believe that the biggest percentage price drops are in appartments and maybe town houses. Standalone houses on their own freehold blocks of land maybe holding up or falling much less. Because Brisbane is late to that party we have less appartments. In my opinion there is far less risk in investing in houses than appartments.
    I think your stats and graphs would tell a more comprehensive story if the dwelling types were split.

  2. Craig Dickeson says:

    Gene, the QLD government/Brisbane Council have three major projects on their horizon: M1/M3, Metro and Cross River. Would significant project announcements,such as these, ease slump? Will there be a flow on in outer suburb residential construction?

    • Gene Tunny says:

      Good point Craig. Thanks. Yes, eventually, although the impacts may be localised, particularly for Metro and CRR. The M1/M3 projects are probably important in guaranteeing the region’s liveability and thus supporting continued interstate migration which boosts demand for properties. Let me think about it some more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s